top of page

Patrolman Richard E. Pelkey
End of Watch: Thursday, August 12, 1954

Cause of Death: Gunfire
Date of Incident: Thursday, August 05, 1954
Weapon Used: Gun
Suspect Info: James A. Call. Released after 13 years

Incident detail: On August 5th, 1954 at approximately 12:30am Lake Placid Police Officers Dominick Valenze, Bernard Fell, Richard Pelkey and John Fagan responded to a suspicious activity call at Dr. Perkins camp on West Valley Rd. There had been several burglaries in the past week including a $100,000.00 jewel theft at the renowned Lake Placid Club. The officers entered the camp and confronted James Call, an AWOL air force major, in the basement where Call was hiding in a shower stall.  Call displayed a gun and a gun battle ensued.   


During the fire fight 14 bullets were fired, 7 by James Call and 5 of which hit their targets injuring all 3 officers and fatally wounding Richard Pelkey who died several days later. A statewide manhunt ensued for James Call.  Lake Placid Police, New York State Police and countless civilians joined the manhunt, manning roadblocks and scouring the 6 million acre Adirondack Park.  Call stayed on the lam for over three months until November 16th, 1954 when a Reno Daily Newspaper reported that James Call was apprehended by the Reno Police Dept.  


Call had been apprehended while attempting to sell a $500 watch at a local pawnshop, reportedly stolen during one of Reno's recent estate burglaries. New York State Police had identified James Call through his fingerprints found at the scene of the Perkins Camp. James Call was convicted for the murder of Officer Richard Pelkey and was sentenced to 20 yrs to life. James call served 13yrs 9 months and 12 days and was released on parole.  Call later died in a car accident in 1974.

Officer Richard Pelkey is listed on the New York State Police Officers Memorial Wall in Albany and the National Law Enforcement Officer's Memorial in Washington, DC.

Pelky's Memorial on the ODMP

cutler no phot.jpg

Patrolman Fred Cutler
End of Watch: Tuesday, July 2, 1907

Cause of Death: Gunfire
Date of Incident: Monday, July 01, 1907
Weapon Used: Gun
Suspect Info: George Delcour. Pardoned by Gov. Whitman after 10 years.

Incident detail:

Patrolman Fred Cutler succumbed to a gunshot wound sustained the previous day while attempting to arrest a man for causing a disturbance in town.

The subject had been driving his horse and buggy recklessly through town and had threatened to kill any officer who attempted to arrest him. The Lake Placid village president ordered Patrolman Cutler and another officer to arrest the subject. They located the man inside a barber shop on Main Street. As the officers entered the shop the subject immediately opened fire, striking Patrolman Cutler in the chest and the other officer in the arm.

The man escaped from the scene but was later captured near Bloomingdale, New York. He was convicted of Patrolman Cutler's murder and sentenced to 20 years in prison.

Cutler's Memorial on the ODMP

bottom of page